[Forbes, James], respondent

Dame Anna Dorothea Byrne, executrix of Sir Daniel Byrne, bar. deceas'd; and Sir John Byrne, an infant, son and heir of Sir Daniel, by the said Dame Anna Dorethea his mother and guardian. Appellants. Robert Harpole. George died before his father without issue. William Sir Robert Hartpole died 1682. William Hartpole, then a minor. George Hartpole. Daniel Byrne, the common ancestor, died 1683. Sir Gregory Byrne, bar. Sir Daniel Byrne, bar. Sir John Byrne. George Hartpole, son and heir of William Hartpole, by his guardian William Wilcocks, Elizabeth Wilcocks, widow of Thomas Wilcocks, Isachar, Sarah, Elizabeth and Abigail Wilcocks, children of the said Thomas Wilcocks, Thomas Robbins administrator with the will annexed of the said Thomas Wilcocks, Edward Cowper and James Forbes, renouncing executors of the said Thomas Wilcocks, John Hayes, and John Mac Culagh, executors of Robert Wilcocks, son and heir of Charles Wilcocks, Robert Wilcocks, son of William Wilcocks, another son of the said Charles Wilcocks, and Robert Wilcocks son of Stephen Wilcocks, and son of the said Charles Wilcocks, which said Robert and Robert Wilcocks, were the devisees of their uncle Robert Wilcocks, Joseph Fade, and Abel Strettell, executors of Joshua Wilcocks, Elizabeth Wilcocks his wodow, and Isachar his son heir, William Wilcocks. Charles Wilcocks. Robert, William and Stephen. Robert devisee of his uncle Robert. Robert devisee of his uncle Robert. Isachar Wilcocks. Joshua and Thomas. Isachar. Isachar, Sarah, Elizabeth and Abigail. Respondent's case